Wednesday, February 22, 2023

Edip Yuksel on Medina, A federal secular republic?

 

 Medina, A federal secular republic?

 

Edip Yuksel is politically progressive and vocal about it. We can even see his politics preach out to us from the pages of his work, which he calls the “Reformist translation of the Qur’an.”  A couple of times Edip Yuksel refers to the early state established by the Muslims as a “federal secular republic.” At other times Yuskel labels the early state of Medina as a “federal secular democracy.”  The words democracy, secular and federal come up time again throughout his translation. Is this best way to refer to the early state of Medianh? We will briefly examine Edip Yuksel’s claims on the nature state established by the Prophet Muhammad.

 

The treaty of Hudayybiyah is an important hallmark in Islamic history. Often referred to as the “constitution” of Medinah, the treaty is certainly a pioneer effort in establishing a just society along the lines of different communities living and thriving together.  The treaty was established by the Prophet Muhammad in an alliance with the non- believing tribes and Jews that inhabited the city of Medinah.  There is always a tendency to exaggerate the good aspects of history. The treaty of Hudayybiyah is in my view proof of the good intentions of the Prophet Muhammad and the nascent Muslim community.  But  how much more can we say about it?  Edip Yuksel believes the treaty is proof that the Prophet had modern concepts of government.  Yuksel uses the treaty and some verses of the Qur’an to attempt to prove his assertions that that Quran exhibits “progressive” notions. Commenting on 2:193 Yuksel writes in the footnote “ God's system is based on freedom of faith and expression. God's system recommends an egalitarian republic, and a federally secular system that allows multiple jurisdictions for different religious or non-religious groups..”   We will see Yukel use the terms “secular” “federal” and “republic” over and over again.

 

In what way would Yuksel argue that the Islamic system established by the Prophet Muhamad was a republic as he comments on 2:193?  Elsewhere, commenting on 4:140 Yuksel said that the early Medinian state  was a “federal secular democracy.” Democracy or republic? Which is it?  We assume that Yuskel would know the difference between the two terms: democracy and republic. We understood that often the terms “democracy” and republic” are used interchangeably.  But Yuksel has an obligation to describe the nature of this republic/democratic state.  What was the nature of participation of the masses of people in the state to make it a democracy? Were there elected representatives to govern Medina like a republic? If so, then who elected them?  We do not really get an answer to these questions in the commentary Edip provides.

 

One claim is made to prove the democratic nature of the state by using the pledge of women to the Prophet as an example. He refers to the pledge as the “right to vote.” Commenting on 60:12 Yuskel writes, “In this verse, the prophet acknowledges women's right to vote, by taking the pledge of believing women to peacefully surrender themselves to God alone and lead a righteous life. The word "BaYA'" used in the verse implies the political nature of the pledge; they accepted the leadership of the prophet individually, with their free choice. This verse is not about some pagan or mushrik women embracing islam, but is about a group of muslim women publicly announcing their allegiance to Muhammad, who became a founder of a federally secular constitutional government in central Arabia…”      According to Yuksel, the example of the women pledging their allegiance to the Prophet is an example of the “right to vote”   He tries to show the arabic baya as indicating a “political nature.”   We then see this as proof of a “federally secular constitutional government.”

 

Yuksel is right that 60:12 is not referring to idolaters who just embraced islam.  Giving baya is not just limited to embracing islam. A pledge is given to reigning caliphs as well as Sufi murshids by people who have long accepted islam.  In both these cases one proclaims loyalty to a respective person. But how exactly the pledge an example of the “right to vote?”  Was there anyone else to give the pledge to?  Sure, the women had the choice not to pledge that alone does not  qualify the situation as a “right to vote.”

 

What is the nature of the pledge to the prophet?  One of the first pledges was at Aqaba when the Prophet traveled to Medinah at the beginning of Hijra.  A hadith attributed to ibn Jarir in Bukhari gives a similar list of duties prescribed to the companions on their pledge to the prophet.  The point of the pledge is to give obedience to the messenger of God. Obedience is not the same as democracy because you cannot un-elect the messenger of God. The verses that discuss obedience to the messenger are well known and elaborated upon in Surah Nisa and elsewhere.  To claim that giving bay3 has anything to do with the right to vote is misleading.

Edip Yuksel describes the system of government as “federal secularism” when commenting on 2:193. What does that term even mean? We need to break these terms down. Yuksel continues about Medinah, that the prophet, “established a successful example of a federal secular system by dividing the territory into independent legal jurisdictions to accommodate the diverse religious, social, and political preferences of its communities.” The treaty of Hudaybiyah established a system in which the various tribes and societies that composed Median had their own respective laws. The Muslims had their courts to use for various affairs and the Jews had their own courts to use which were independent of Muslim jurisdiction.  Yuksel gives the example in Surah 5:83 where the Prophet asks a group of Jews why they take legislation from him when they have the Torah. A federal system of government has a strong central authority but allows for internal affairs.  The system at Medinah could be described as federal in this sense but it was one based on tribal societies and not based on the modern notions of a state that came into being after the treaty of Westphalia on modern times.

 

Where does the “secularism” come into the Medina society?  Yuksel finds it apparently in the non-coercive religious authority that existed in Medina. But a lack of religious of coercion need not imply secularism. When the debate about secularism comes up we often bring up the subject the separation of church and state.  Could we really describe early Islam as being subservient to such notions? Yuksel believes the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah  manifested secularism due to non-coercive character of the constitution which is true. But did the treaty advocate a “secular” environment like the one we talk about where there is a separation of church and state?  That would be a weak argument. It is well known that in the original draft of the Treaty the Jews told Hazrat Ali to remove the words “messenger of God” by the Prophet’s name. “O Ali! Delete it and write ‘Muhammad b. Abdullah’.” (Sahih Muslim; Ahmad.)  Ali did not want to remove the term but Muhammad consented to it eventually.  No one would call a document “secular” that had the word “messenger of God attached.”  Of course the term “messenger of God” was not in the ratified agreement but the intention of the founders was well known.  The society of Medinah was not one in which one group coerced the others to have another faith. But to argue that the society was “secular” is problematic. 

 

The terms “secular” and “federal” have to do with modern notions of the state that did not exist at the time of the Qur’an reception.  I agree with Edip Yuksel that the society created by the Prophet manifested some values that modern egalitarian thinkers can look upon as being noteworthy for contemporary political issues. However to label the early Medina society as a “democracy” or “secular” creates anachronistic problems. When we read the Qur’an the believer had the double task of not sacrificing their own values (the way fundamentalists do)  but also the other task of not trying to push their own values into the Qur’an itself.

 

 

 

Does Quran forbid hadith?

 

        Does Quran forbid hadith?

 

Many people who consider themselves  Qu’an only followers (or Quranists) disregard hadith for any theological purpose. The people who constitute Quransits have a wide variety of beliefs and man do not have a clear ideological agenda. There are a small group of Quranists group that take a stronger stance against hadith however. They aregue that not only should hadith be disregarded but that hadith is forbidden by the Qur’an Dr. Rashad Khalifa and his students argued that hadith is a satanic innovation.  To make their point Dr. Khalifa and his followers argued that the Qur’an explicitly forbids hadith from use. Furthermore, they argue that the use of hadith constitutes idolatry. Does the Qur’an forbid the use of hadith?  We will explore the arguments of the Quranists.

 

The start of our enquiry demands it appropriate we define out terms. What is a hadith? A hadith is considered for a narration that records the words and actions attributed to the Prophet Muhammad.  This is the definition of hadith that is widespread for colloquial in Arabic and other languages. A hadith in this context may have a broader meaning to include sayings and actions of companions, without reference to the Prophet. There are many such hadiths included in the popular “sahih” books that are considered hadith despite not having the Prophet mentioned as a source.  In any case this definition of hadith as a narration that refers to the Prophet is the one subject of debate between Quranists and everyone else.  This definition of hadith however as information that refers in some way to the Prophet Muhammad is a limited definition that developed at some time in history.  Before there was a Bukhari or Muwatta collection, the word hadith had a more expansive definition.  Therefore, we are obligated to seek a more expansive understanding of hadith that won’t get trapped in  anachronistic reasoning. Would the Prophet and his companions understand our use of the word hadith in the same way? No.

 

What is the definition of hadith according to the Qur’an?How the Qur’an and people contemporary to the Qur’an’s revelation are vital to understand the meaning of hadith. The Qur’an provides a number  of examples for us. We should review them and then come up with a general idea on how we can understand hadith based on the Qur’an alone.

The way that Rashad Khalifa and his followers understand hadith is what most of us are concerned with. There are verses in the Qur’an that refer to information outside the Quran as hadith. These references appear to be negative. We will cite verses that Dr. Khalifa used for arguments against hadith.  “ [7:185] Have they not looked at the dominion of the heavens and the earth, and all the things GOD has created? Does it ever occur to them that the end of their life may be near? Which Hadith, beside this, do they believe in?”, “[77:50] Which Hadith, other than this, do they uphold?” [31:6] The previous two verses require more comment but just need to be told for now. Another verse speaks about “baseless” hadith. 31:6 “Among the people, there are those who uphold baseless Hadith, and thus divert others from the path of GOD without knowledge, and take it in vain. These have incurred a shameful retribution. “        Surely, if a hadith is baseless it could not have much value. The above verses are listed in Quranists polemics.

 

But the Qur’an does not limit the definition of hadith to this outside information.  In fact, the  Qur’an refers to itself as hadith:”[39:23] GOD has revealed herein the best Hadith; a book that is consistent, and points out both ways (to Heaven and Hell). The skins of those who reverence their Lord cringe therefrom, then their skins and their hearts soften up for GOD's message. Such is GOD's guidance; He bestows it upon whomever He wills. As for those sent astray by GOD, nothing can guide them.” The Qur’an is called the best hadith. The Quranists are aware of verses like this and cite them as evidence against hadith they do not like (Bukhari, sunan hadith,etc.) The Qur’an tells us how bad it is to reject a hadith such as the holy writ : 68:44] Therefore, let Me deal with those who reject this Hadith; we will lead them on whence they never perceive.”   If the Qur’an is hadith then obviously not all hadith is bad. The Qur’an is included in the definition of hadith and therefore a more expansive definition of hadith is required.

 

The references to the past prophets are found throughout the Qur’an. “51:24] Have you noted the history of Abraham's honorable guests?” The story about Abraham and his guests is found in the book of Genesis, the first book of the Torah. Elsewhere the Qur’an makes mention of Moses “[20:9] Have you noted the history of Moses?” This verse also references the Torah. Both of the cited verses use the word “hadth” in arabic to refer to the narration of those stories which are found in the bible. The use of the word “hadith” is positive in these cases. The Qur’an is making reference to the stories from previous scriptures to teach a lesson to the readers.  The use of the term hadith may not be known to followers of Dr. Khalifa because he  did not choose to leave the word “hadith” untranslated in these cases. However, students of the Qur’an even with minimal knowledge would be aware that references to biblical stories are marked by the term hadith. It is therefor evident that a type of hadith exists outside of the Qur’an which has a positive nature.  The Qur’an is referencing the Torah and other books of the bible like the Gospels or Zubor to prove a point. But for the Qur’an to use these stories the reader is expected to accept the validity of the stories to the degree that the Qur’an deems necessarily.  If all hadith, other than Qur’an, were deemed false than the Qur’an would not use the term “hadith” to refer to previous revelatory dispensations.

 

References to the bible are not the only information that the Qur’an refers to as hadith.  “[12:6] "Your Lord has thus blessed you, and has given you good news through your dream. He has perfected His blessings upon you and upon the family of Jacob, as He did for your ancestors Abraham and Isaac before that. Your Lord is Omniscient, Most Wise." There is a whole Surah in the Qur’an entitled Joseph. The prophet Joseph was recognized as an interpreter of dreams. The verse in the original arabic uses the word hadith to refer to dreams in fact.  Again in the same chapter we read “[12:21] The one who bought him in Egypt said to his wife, "Take good care of him. Maybe he can help us, or maybe we can adopt him." We thus established Joseph on earth, and we taught him the interpretation of dreams. GOD's command is always done, but most people do not know.” The word hadith is used in the arabic to refer to dreams that must be interpreted.  Dreams share a rank in the information sources similar to that of biblical narrations in the view of the Qur’an.  Both these information sources are considered valid paths for knowledge. Both also serve to elucidate the passages in the Qur’an.   Dreams, like biblical narrations, are a source of information outside the Qur’an which are seen in a positive light and are thus referred to as “hadith.” We also should note that Dr. khalifa did not choose to interpret the word “hadith” to refer to dreams here.

 

One last example of the word “Hadith” in the Qur’an comes from Surah 66.” [66:3] The prophet had trusted some of his wives with a certain statement, then one of them spread it, and GOD let him know about it. He then informed his wife of part of the issue, and disregarded part. She asked him, "Who informed you of this?" He said, "I was informed by the Omniscient, Most Cognizant."   In this case the Prophet learned information directly from God concerning a matter with one of his wives.  The word hadith is use here in this verse. Pay attention to the words “He then informed his wife of part of the issue, and disregarded part.” The literal translation would be "he made known a part of it and avoided a part." Dr. Khalifa’s use of the word “issue” although not incorrect, does not reflect the plain meaning of the text.  The arabic word “part of it (badahu)” is referring to the arabic “hadith” in the same verse. Thus God gave the Prophet information (hadith) about something related to his wives. In that process of revelation some of the information (hadith) was invalidated but other parts of the information was deemed truthful. Thus we see that the Qur’an did not totally invalidate the “hadith” in question. Instead, the Qur’an affirmed part of the hadith and denied the other part. If al hadith was condemned by the Qur’an we would not expect to see such a statement like that of 66:3.

 

No where in the Qur’an does it explicitly reject hadith in general. There is no verse that says all hadith are bad. Dr. Khalifa and his followers constructed such claims by ignoring the way the Qur’an actually discusses hadith. There are times when hadith is accepted and other times when hadith is rejected. Ultimately, one could construct an argument against hadith independent of what the Qur’an says. But the claim of some Quranists, that all “hadith” is denied by Qur’an does not hold up to scrutiny.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Which hadith besides the Qur’an do they believe in?

 

Which hadith besides the Qur’an do they believe in?

 

Does the Qu’ran contain instructions to deny all information outside of the qur’an? The disciples of the Qur’an only movement argue that the holy writ does people explicitly to disregard hadith. They often quote Dr. Rashad Khalifa’s translation wherein it is asked “in which hadith do they believe in other than the Qur’an?” This question appears in multiple forms in the following verses: 7:185, 45:6, 52:34 and 77:50.  Is the Qur’an making this statement to deny any hadith besides the Qur’an? Our discussion of the four verses will seek to understand if the common Qur’anist interpretations line up with a contextual analysis.

 

[7:185] Have they not looked at the dominion of the heavens and the earth, and all the things GOD has created? Does it ever occur to them that the end of their life may be near? Which Hadith, beside this, do they believe in?

 

We first encounter the question “Which hadith do they believe in?” with Surah Araf. We are encountered in 7:185 with a question about divine providence in the universe that a believer should note when the world is contemplated.  With the vastness of the heavens and the short life span of human beings we should note that there must be something more to the world than what the foolish attribute to it. It is obvious when it is asked, “Which Hadith, beside this, do they believe in?” that “besides this” refers only to the Qur’an. What does the Qur’an have in mind that it is juxtaposing itself to a hadith? The context makes this clear. “[7:182] As for those who reject our revelations, we lead them on without them ever realizing it.” We are told that the Qur’an has something to say about the rejectors and their claim that the Prophet was crazy (ibid 184.)  It is the context of encountering rejectors of divine revelation that 7:185 seeks to elucidate.  The verse is essentially asking us to complete the universe for God’s signs.  The Qur’an is our guide to understand the world and our purpose in it. By asking the disbelievers “which hadith” do they believe in besides the Qur’an, they are being asked if they have a better explanation for the world. What information do they have to counter the message of the Qur’an?

 

45:6] These are GOD's revelations that we recite to you truthfully. In which Hadith other than GOD and His revelations do they believe?

Dr. Rashad Khalifa believes Surah jathiyah 45:6 is antagonistic to hadith when it is asked “in which hadith other than God and His revelations do they believe?”  Dr. Khalifa writes in the footnote to the verse, “God condemns "Hadith" by name, and informs us that it is a blasphemous fabrication.” But the context to the discussion appears just as we saw in Surah araf. “[45:5] Also, the alternation of the night and the day, and the provisions that GOD sends down from the sky to revive dead lands, and the manipulation of the winds; all these are proofs for people who understand.” The verse right before Surah 45:6 asks us to reflect on the world at large. Earlier we noted the vase expanse of the universe but here in surah 45 we are talking about the movement in time. Just as we see a change from the night till day in a continuous cycle and we see the change of seasons as reflected by the earth’s vegetation, we should understand our place in the cycle of things.  In 45:3 the Qur’an says that the world is “full proof” for believers.  Yet the disbelievers do not listen and must be warned of a painful retribution 45:8.

 

If the disbelievers deny God’s signs in the universe than what else do they have to offer as an explanation? Which other hadith do they believe in?  Obviously, a hadith talking about the Prophet’s interactions with people has nothing to do with what type of “hadith” the Qur’an has in mind. The Qur’an is asking the unbeliever for an alternative explanation. Perhaps one can be sought in a popular atheist publication. The challenge is there just as we saw in surah Araf.

 

What about Dr. Khalifa’s footnote where he alleges “God condemns hadith by name.”  Dr. Khalifa must have read the Qur’an in the most superficial or deceptive manner to come up with this conclusion. We have discussed earlier how hadith has a range in meanings. The Qur’an is called the best hadith. Dreams are called hadith and accepted as valid information.  The Qur’an condemns “vain hadith.” The previous scriptures has stories referred to as hadith.  We see that hadith has a vast amount of meaning that all deal with information of one sort or another. The highest level of hadith is the qur’an itself which is highly praised. Lower levels of hadith include other types of revelation such as dreams, intuition but any information such as a book or a book of hadiths would be included in category of hadith.  The Qur’an obviously does not condemn all these categories of hadith but only the lowest categories.  That every “ hadith is condemned by name” is false. Nor is the Qur’an even discussing the type of hadiths that are attributed to the prophet and the companions, as we discussed above.

[52:34] Let them produce a Hadith like this, if they are truthful.

 

Surah Tour presents us with a challenge to produce a hadith like the Qur’an in 52:34.  Dr. Khalifa writes in the subtitle on top of the verse ,” "Mohammedans" Challenge God and Produce Hadith.” He evidently thinks the “hadiths” mentioned here are the same hadiths of the writings of the narration collections attributed to the prophet and early personalities. Is this really so?

 

The context for 52:34 provides us with the frame for the discussion.  On the allegations made against the Prophet ,” you are neither a soothsayer, nor crazy” (52:29.) The allegation that the Prophet was mentally unsound is mentioned a couple of times in the Qur’an. The disbelievers call the Prophet a “poet.” (ibid 30) The disbelievers doubt the prophet’s mission so strongly they advise each other to wait for his death. The Qur’an tells the prophet to respond that he will wait with them.  52:31.  The Qur’an asks the disbelievers furthermore if they allege the prophet forged the revelation.  The disbelievers are asked if the universe was created from nothing or if they themselves contributed to their creation(ibid 35)

 

The question, “which hadith” do they believe, is a challenge to the disbelievers just as the previous verses were. We are asked to contemplate the creation of the universe and this time the prophet’s mission specifically.  When the Qur’an asks if people really believe it is a forgery we are asked to contemplate the verses themselves so we can ascertain the truth for ourselves.

 

The question “which hadith.. like the Qur”an” is similar to another question we see mentioned several times in the holy writ. [2:23] If you have any doubt regarding what we revealed to our servant,* then produce one sura like these, and call upon your own witnesses against GOD, if you are truthful.” The challenge to produce a work like the Qur’an is well known. The challenges to produce a work of information are one and the same.  There is no reason to believe the vast amount of orthodox Muslims are being challenged with any of these verses.

 

And of Dr. Khalifa’s subtitle to 52:31 “Mohammedans" Challenge God and Produce Hadith” ? Obviously,52:31 is not a challenge to the believers in hadith. The verse is a challenge to the disbelievers in the Qur’an’s revelation.  The disbelievers deny the divine origins of the planet and the existence of revelation. The so-called Mohammedans deny neither.  The subject matter of the hadith books hardly deal with matters of creation and revelation. The hadith books are mostly records about worship, ethical dealings, applied jurisprudence, etc.

 

[77:50] Which Hadith, other than this, do they uphold?

 

The last verse of Surah Musalaat asks “Which hadith” other than this(quran) do they uphold.  We ask who is the Qur’an talking to? The previous verse 77:49 warns the rejectors of truth and those that refuse to bow down (ibid 48.) The refusal to bow before God is a trademark of Satan.  The question posed to the disbelievers is the same question posed as the other verses  proclaim.  It is not a question for people who believe in the Qur’an and also hadiths.

 

As we saw in our analysis of the above verses, the challenge to the disbelievers does not have anything to do with juxtaposing Qur’an with “hadiths” of the canonical type in the way Dr. Khalfia wants us to believe.  To claim that the “hadith” being attacked in the Qur’an refers to the modern hadith collections (Which didn’t exist at the time of the Prophet) is anachronistic as we learned. Hadith has an expansive meaning in the Qur’an and not all hadiths are condemned.  The hadith referred to in these challenges are specific information juxtaposed to what the Qur’an is saying. In other words, if the Qur’an is saying that the world was crate by God then what information do disbelievers have to counter the divine claim?  Aside from contradictory hadith, the vast majority of hadith are congruent with the information in the Qur’an or have nothing to do with the subject matter. Obviously the claim of being congruent has nothing to do with the authenticity of hadith.  But there is no reason to conclude that the canonical hadiths are being challenged here.  Although any work that contradicts the Qur’an should be disputed.

 

If one wants to ask the question, “which hadith do they believe in?” outside of the context of the Quranic discussion then that is their right.  I would agree with the Quranists that the above verses could be used to argue against hadith and any other information that contradicts the Qur’an. But to juxtapose those Quranic questions to any and all information outside of the Qur’an is out of place and incoherent. If the Qur’an denied all outside information there would be more proof of this throughout the Qur’an. But the Qur’an never denies every source of information. The Qur’an as the Furqan is the means of discernment between good and bad information. Therefor if the Quranists ask “which hadith do you believe in” other than Qur’an then the response is any information is believed which is congruent with the Qur’an.  

 

 

 

Wednesday, February 15, 2023

A Qur’anic prophecy about a medieval rabbi.

 

A Qur’anic prophecy about a medieval rabbi.  

 

One of the more humorous claims of Rashad Khalifa concerns an interpretation of a verse in Surah Ahqaf. Dr. Khalifa believers Surah 46:10 was revealed as prophecy about Rabbi Yehuda Ha Hasid. Rashad believed that this 13th century mystic confirmed the Qur’an’s 19 based numerical structure of revelation. We addressed Dr. Khalifa’s claims about the math-miracle in previous scriptures in-depth already. We will focus on Dr. Khalifa’s interpretation of 46:10. Dr. Khalifa translates the verse as follows:

 

[46:10] Say, "What if it is from GOD and you disbelieved in it? A witness from the Children of Israel has borne witness to a similar phenomenon,* and he has believed, while you have turned arrogant. Surely, GOD does not guide the wicked people."

 

The subtitle to 46:10 in the “Final Testament” has the name of the Jewish mystic:  Rabbi Judah the Pious.    It is puzzling at first sight why the name of a lesser known rabbi would make the pages of a Qur’an translation.  Dr. Khalifa tells us the reason for the title in the footnote: *46:10 This witness is Rabbi Judah the Pious (11th Century A.D.), who discovered the same 19-based mathematical code in intact fragments of the scripture (see Appendix 1)

 

Dr. Rashad Khalifa claimed that the “witness from the children of Israel” was none other than Rabbi Judah the Pius.  Rashad thought that the similar phenomena described had to do with the mathematical codes, allegedly in both scriptures. Dr. Khalifa claimed that Rabbi Yehuda discovered these codes in “intact fragments” of the “scripture.”   Edip Yuksel, in his “Reformist translation of the qur’an” writes that Rabbi Yehuda discovered this pattern “in the original parts of the old testament” (Reformist Translation, Yuskel,Edip pg. 321, footnote 46:10)

 

What are these “intact fragments” Dr. Rashad Khalifa is referring to? Edip Yuksel, just as his mentor, believe these fragments are the “original parts of the old testament..”  Is that really the case? Dr. Rashad Khalifa found the source of his claim in Studies of Jewish Mysticism by Joseph Dan. We addressed the problems with Dr. Khalifa’s interpretation of the evidence elsewhere. But no where in Studies of Jewish mysticism does it refer to “intact fragments” or even a reference to the “old testament.”  Joseph Dan tells us name of the text written by Yehuda called Sodot ha Tefilah (Secrets of the Liturgy) which by name tell us is a commentary on the liturry. Sodot ha Tefilah is a commentary on the Amidah prayer, a liturgy not found in the bible but created by rabbis during the time of the second temple era.  Someone knowledgeable in Judaism would not make the mistake that Dr. Khalifa and Edip Yuksel made.  Dr. Khalifa did in identifying the text Joseph Dan and Rabbi Yehuda were talking about.   Edip Yuksel was wrong in identifying the text as part of the “old testament.” Dr. Khalifa however was intentionally misleading by using the term “intact fragments” to describe the text in question as Joseph Dan never used any of these terms. In fact copies of the Amidah prayer are found everywhere (just as they were in the days of Rabbi Yehudah.)  But Dr. Khalifa wants us to believe that there was some pure manuscript of the Torah that Yehudah had access to but this is nothing but deceit.

 

Who was the witness to the children of Israel in 46:10. Many of the traditions refer to Abdullah ibn Salam as the witness among the Israelites as he converted to Islam during the time of the prophet.  The problem with this interpretation according to some people as that the Surah was revealed in Mecca and Abdullah did not convert to islam until the believers established themselves in Madinah. Other commentaries believe the witness is Moses based on the prophecy of a prophet to come like unto him found in the book of Deuteronomy.  We share Dr. Khalifa’s opinion (which he followed rather inconsistently) that the Qur’an should be interpreted universally and not limited to a specific time and place. Maulauna Maudoodi, summing up the opinion of ibn kathir writes ,” What seems to be nearer the truth is that which the commentator Nisaburi and Ibn Kathir have stated. They say: Here, by a witness is not meant any particular person but a common Israelite. The meaning is this: The teachings that the Quran is presenting before you are not new so that you could deny them by offering the excuse that they were novel teachings which had never been presented before man in the past.” (Towards understanding the Quran) And God knows best.

 

Mathematical codes in previous scripture?

 

Mathematical codes in previous scripture?

 

Dr. Rashad Khalifa claimed that the previous revelations were composed according to the same mathematical pattern that he found in the Qur’an. Dr. Khalifa cites a medieval rabbinical source to bolster his claim. The source is attributed to Yehuda Ha Hasid (Judah ben Samuel of Regensburg 1150-1217), a Jewish mystic.  We will evaluate Dr. Khalifa’s evidence  to determine its viability as weight for the claim that divine scripture is mathematically composed. We will also discuss the problematic implications of the claim towards “mathematical” revelations.

 

The claim that previous divine revelations were composed mathematically  is well known. Dr. Khalifa used a reference he found in STUDIES IN JEWISH MYSTICISM , (Association for Jewish Studies, Cambridge, Mass., Joseph Dan & Frank Talmage, eds., Page 88, 1982), an old academic publication. The entry in STUDIES in Jewish Mysticism contains a quote from Yehuda Ha Hasid, a figure known to students of Jewish thought. Dr. Khalifa cites the claim in the first appendix to his Qur’an translations. Rashad however introduced the claim as early as July of 1985 in the Muslim Perspectives newsletter.  Dr. Khalifa was so happy about the quotation that he makes mention of it footnote Surah 46:10. Dr. Khalifa goes as far as to say 46:10 is a previous concerning Yeduha ha Hasid.  The followers of Dr. Rashad Khalifa such as Lisa Spray and Abdullah Arik continued to cite the source in their respective books (Jesus Myth and Message, chapter 9; Beyond Probability pg. 47)

 

We will cite the relevant quotation from Studies in Jewish Mysticism here:

 

The people [Jews] in France made it a custom to add [in the morning prayer] the words: " 'Ashrei temimei derekh [blessed are those who walk the righteous way]," and our Rabbi, the Pious, of blessed memory, wrote that they were completely and utterly wrong. It is all gross falsehood, because there are only nineteen times that the Holy Name is mentioned [in that portion of the morning prayer]... and similarly you find the word 'Elohim nineteen times in the pericope of Ve-'elleh shemot. . . . Similarly, you find that Israel were called "sons" nineteen times, and there are many other examples. All these sets of nineteen are intricately intertwined, and they contain many secrets and esoteric meanings, which are contained in more than eight large volumes. . . Furthermore, in this section there are 152 (19x8) words (pg. 88, 89 Dan, Joseph ibid)

 

Dr. Rashad Khalifa thought he found gold when he saw the above article in the academic journal. For Rashad and his followers, the notion that other scriptures previous to Qur’an contained a mathematical formula was proof of their assertions.  If the Torah or Injeel could be proven to be composed mathematically than it would be obvious that the Qur’an was also composed in the same manner. In fact, it would be a disservice to the Qur’an if it was not composed mathematically yet the previous scriptures were.  Were the previous scriptures composed mathematically? Dr. Khalifa and his followers continue to peddle Joseph Dan’s book to “prove” that not only were the previous scriptures composed mathematically but composed mathematically around the number 19.

 

Dr. Rashad Khalifa claims that the quote attributed to Yehuda Ha Hasid proves that that previous scripture is mathematically composed around the number 19.  Therefore, he did not want changes to it. The problem with the quotation is that Yehuda Ha Hasid is not talking about the Torah or any “scripture.” Rabbi Yehuda is discussing the text of the Amidah prayer also known as the Shimone Esreh (18 Benedictions.) The Amidah prayer is not believed in Judaism to be divine revelation in the sense of the Torah or prophetic writings. The Amidah prayer is believed by Jewish authorities to be composed by the men of the great assembly (knessset ha Gadol) some time prior to the destruction of the second temple. Interestingly there are 19 blessings in the semeoneh esreh (the Hebrew number shemoneh means 18) despite the fact there are 19 blessings recited today. But the 19th blessing was added to the prayer at a later time. This final prayer which asks for the separation from heretics is believed to be made by the pre-rabbinical orthodoxy as a response to the Jewish followers of Jesus.

 

It is true that the Rabbi believed the item he was referring to was composed mathematically and wanted to use this as proof to not initiate any changes to the prayer.  Rabbi Yehuda was a kabbalist and gematria is a prevalent belief for them. The Amidah prayer is believed to be a holy prayer since it was believed to be composed by pious rabbis inspired by the holy spirit. But in any case the Amidah is not believed to be dictated by God.  Kabbalist thought no doubt is recognized as a valid thinking by Orthodoxy. It would not be correct to attribute the views of Rabbi Yehuda to be widespread.  Rabbi Yehuda himself would probably not view the Amidah in the same position as that of the Torah even if he believed the prayers were mathematically composed. The Amidah prayer is not scripture for Jews in any sense. Therefore, this particular prayer is not proof that Jews believed the scriptures were mathematically composed or composed specifically around the number 19.

 

There are many Jewish faithful that believe the Torah is mathematically composed. Orthodox Judaism does hold it a fundamental of faith to believe the Torah is written by God and given to Moses. The writings of Maimonides and other rabbis deem it necessary to believe that even the letters and particular spellings are from God. There is of course some variation that exists among orthodox faithful to this belief when it comes to the questions of the death of Moses being mentioned in the Torah or issues dealing with manuscripts that are beyond the subject here.  The Kabbalist world has spent a lot of time paying attention to gematria by finding interesting patterns in the Torah but I am not aware of any rabbinical theory that claims the whole Torah is based on a specific mathematical pattern in the way that Dr. Khalifa viewed.  Thirty years ago a famous book came out called the “The Bible Codes” which claimed to find certain patterns in the Torah based on letter skipping but these claims are considered amusement but not necessarily serious for most Jews.   

 

There are false premises behind the notion that any of the revelations contained numerical codes of any kind. Dr. Khalifa wanted people to believe that scripture was mathematically composed. But what exactly is scripture and why should it be significant?  Scripture is nothing but the manuscripts where divine revelations are written. So the real question is whether revelation, the divine communication between God and man, is numerically composed.  The Qur’an in the first place in addition to the previous scriptures speak about revelatory phenomena in a natural way without books falling from the sky. If revelation is something that comes to the heart then how could we talk about finding numerical patterns in written words when the words are at best verbal communications from the divine? We spoke about these questions elsewhere. Dr. Khalifa realized that belief in a mathematically coded revelations depended on books descriptions. That is why he wrongly claimed the Qur’an was given to the Prophet all at once in a book form. This is also why he considered the “mathematical miracle” to be physical in orientation.  But the claims are wrong.

 

 

 

 

 

Hussain’s martyrdom according to Dr. Khalifa

 

Hussain’s martyrdom according to Dr. Khalifa.

 

Dr. Rashad Khalifa sees the tragedy of Karbala as marking the final stage of the “50” year war. This war according to Rashad’s revisionist, incoherent, history, was part of the chronologically-problematic conspiracy theory to add the “false” verses to the Qur’an. Naturally, Dr. Khalifa must have something to say about Imam Hussain and the tragedy of Karbala. This paper will explore how Dr. Khalifa will make Karbala fit into the revisionist history. Since Dr. Khalifa does not say much we can limit the length of this article.

 

Dr. Rashad Khalifa mentions Imam Hussain twice in his Final Testament, Qur’an translation. A reference is made to the grandson of the Prophet in the Appendix 24 and the Proclamation at the beginning pages of the translation. In both parts of the book Dr. Khalifa states that the battle of Karbala marked the end of the 50 year struggle to preserve the Qur’an.  He does not tell us more information. However, Dr. Khalifa has a little more to say (but not much) in an old issue of the Muslim Perspective from May of 1987. The  front page of the newsletter is titled "THE RESTORATION OF AN IMPORTANT ISLAMIC TRUTH: IMAM ALI & IMAM HUSSEIN DID NOT FIGHT FOR POWER They were Martyred Trying To Protect Qur'an."

 

What “Islamic truth” does Dr. Khalifa have in mind? We need to  summarize what Dr. Khalifa has to say. The article begins:

 

“Ali and Hussein gave their lives attempting to remove two false sentences falsely added at the end of the last Sura revealed in Medina, namely, Sura Tawbah (No. 9).” Rashad attributed the insertion of 9:128-129 to Uthman’s committee. The insertion of the “false” verses  brought about ,”Tremendous turmoil, the Great Fitnah, followed the injection of the two false verses, and ‘Uthman’s assassination.”

 

As we learned earlier, Dr. Khalifa stated that the war (fitnah) lasted 50 years and culminated in Hussain’s death.  It was after this time that Marwan ibn Hakam destroyed the  “original” Qur’an. As Dr. Khalifa writes in the newsletter, “After the war was settled, and Hussein had been martyred, the Umayyad Khalifa Marwan Ibn Al-Hakam (who died in the year 65 AH) destroyed the Prophet’s Qur’an”  The rest of the article then asks questions related to the two verses and we do not hear anything more about Imam Hussain.

 

Dr. Khalifa commits multiple errors here. Marwan ibn Hakam died 66 AH and not 65 AH. This error is not a big deal in itself but I refer the readers the earlier section of this series in which we discussed Dr. Khalifa’s chronology of events, which we found to be so incoherent that it is barely refutable.  We also listed the problems with Imam Hussain and Karbala as part of Rashad’s version of events on the spin-doctored time line. But here in this issue Dr. Khalifa said that the war “was settled” with Imam Hussain’s martyrdom. As we discussed earlier, the war was far from settled and Imam Hussain’s martyrdom was the beginning of a second fitnah that would last another six years. Marwan ibn Hakam would die before the second fitnah ended.  But Dr. Khalifa only mentioned one fitnah which he claimed began with Uthman’s committee to produce Qur’ans (but actually began with Uthman’s own assassination.)

 

Dr. Rashad Khalifa wants us to believe that Imam Hussain’s martyrdom was a result of the Prophet’s grandson’s attempt to “save” the Qur’an. How does Dr. Khalifa try to reframe the known history? The only thing Dr. Khalifa tells us is what he mentions in the title of the newsletter, that Imam Hussain’s calling was not based on a “fight for power.”  But Dr. Khalifa does not tell us any more information. So by denying that Imam Hussain was fighting for power, Dr. Khalifa thinks that this will suffice to convince us Imam Hussain was fighting to preserve the Qur’an.

 

One can legitimately ask if Imam Hussain’s struggle  was based on his desire for power.  Of course Muslims raised to honor the grandson of the Prophet, both among the Sunni and Shia, would deny such a conception. Imam Hussain is considered to be an infallible morally or at least very pious with no trace of ego according to many people.  Dr. Khalifa may argue (but he does not bother to do so) implicitly based on the little he has to say that if Imam Hussain fought for power that this would imply the Prophet’s grandson was hungry for power and egotistical. The fact is that the historical sources say that Imam Hussain saw the appointed Caliph, Yazid ibn Muawiya as illegitimate. He also saw himself as the rightful successor for the Muslim world.  In fact Yazid was viewed as extremely corrupted by many people and illegitimate since he did not have the backing of important Islamic leader (Hussain being among them.)   What would someone concerned about justice and saving Islam do in such a scenario?  Imam Hussain was a pious Muslim and seen as a legitimate successor because of his knowledge and relation to the Prophet.   Imam Hussain truly believed that Yazid’s continued rule would mean the death of Islam and he saw himself as the only one who could religion in such a terrible state.   Anyone is free to disagree with my opinion and historians are welcome to derive what they want from history. But the mere fact that someone fought for power does not necessarily imply that they had a hunger for power any more than it implies they had a true desire to reform society.

 

Dr. Khalifa’s assertion that Imam Hussain fought power (which he sees as the reason according to standard history) is stupid and hypocritical.  Earlier, in the June 1986 issue of MuslimPerspective (as we learned in Slander against Ayesha and Rashad’s debacle)  Dr. Khalifa  tries to defend Abu Bakr based on the slander made against Ayesha. Here, Dr. Khalifa writes “Abu Bakr was the servant of God, and closest friend of the Prophet, who was hated most by the early Shi’as.”  The whole article was devoted to Ayesha, which has nothing to do with Abu Bakr.   If Dr. Khalifa really believes that Abu Bakr was the “servant of God” and the “closest friend” of the Prophet then why does he not try to defend Abu Bakr in his role  in the events of banu Saqifah or the so-called “murtad” wars?  Among the Shia, there is an argument that Abu Bakr was seeking power after the Prophet’s death, at the expense of Ali, who is viewed as the rightful heir to the Prophet.  The event of the banu Saqifah is viewed as problematic in the Sunni-Shia polemics because it appears Abu Bakr and Umar were fighting for power.  If Dr. Khalifa feels it is so important to deny the assertion that Imam Hussain was power hungry then why did  Rashad not make such as argument with regards to Abu Bakr, the man he calls a “servant of God” and “best friend” of the Prophet? It is evident that Dr. Khalifa lets his unconscious Sunnism come to light in his veneration towards Abu Bakr at the expense of Imam Hussain.

 Although most of his followers conveniently forget, Dr. Rashad Khalifa proclaimed himself the head of the United Islamic Nation (UIN). Rashad said himself as head of a world government that was soon to emerge, once people adopted his ideas. This was all in addition to his role as the "messenger of the covenant."  Is not the call for world power egotistical?   Dr. Rashad Khalifa's call for world power places him well above Sadam Hussein, Gamal Nasr, nevermind  Napoleon, Mussolini or  Adolf Hitler (who only sought power over Europe)  and somewhere beside perhaps Genghis Khan.  But at least Genghis Khan had a better reason take power. Would Dr. Khalifa have us believe he only wanted to be ruler over billions of Muslins so he could take out the two false verses (and tear down some tombs?)


Dr. Rashad Khalifa wants us to believe that Imam Hussain’s fight was about purifying the Qur’an of the two “false” verses.  If this is what Dr. Khalifa really believes then how would Dr. Khalifa explain the recorded history in general?  How would Dr. Khalifa explain Imam Hussain’s problem with Yazid? What was Hussain’s motive to travel to Kufa and why did the residents of Kufa ask Hussain to go there in the first place? In what way would we explain the betrayal by the people of Kufa?  What was the motive for Yazid in destroying Hussain and his followers at Karbala?  Would Dr. Khalifa’s followers argue that  Yazid was  trying to prevent Imam Hussain from  taking out the  two verses (9:128-129) from the Qur’an manuscripts?  Dr. Khalifa is free to argue his case about the versions of events in history but he has a responsibility to answer all of these questions above dealing with Imam Hussain.  If Dr. Khalifa wants to deny all of the events he needs to tell us why.  Dr. Khalifa has very little to say and only wants people to believe him at his word as a “messenger of the covenant.”   Dr. Khalifa’s version of events probably should not even be considered “revisionist” because he revises nothing and merely makes assertions.  Indeed, Dr. Khalifa’s history is almost too incoherent to even refute.

Tuesday, February 14, 2023

Revelation outside the Qur’an

 

        Revelation outside the Qur’an

 

How do we understand the experience of revelation to the Prophet Muhammad in the Qur’an? The Qur’an is considered divine revelation to all who profess islam. Traditional sources state that Muhammad received the Qur’an  as well other revelations in addition to the holy writ.  The notion that the Prophet received non-Quranic revelations has been challenged by some modern thinkers who adopted a Quran-only ideology, a way of thinking that seems to believe the Qur’an is a self-contained document.  But is there really any evidence for the assumption that the Qur’an is self-contained?  We will examine some Quranic verses that indicate the Prophet received revelation outside of the Qur’an. Our research will show the Qur’an that is better to understand the Qur’an not as a self-contained book but a referential standard for revelation.

 

There seems to be an assumption among Muslims about the Qur’an in that the prophet Muhammad received revelation in the form of the Qur’an.  It is true that this is not an opinion from scholarly sources as the traditional view is that Muhammad received revelation in addition to the Qur’an.  Scholars classified non-quranic revelation as  wahi ghayri matlu.  Nevertheless assumptions that only the Quran was provided as revelation continues to dominate.  The growth of Qur’an only ideology has fed upon the assumption that the Prophet’s revelation was limited to the Qur’an. In it’s task to cleanse Islam of hadith, sunnah, etc.. Quranists have found it useful to deny revelation outside of the Qur’an and have thus amplified unwarranted assumptions of the mass of traditional oriented believers. I should say from the outset that the denial of outside revelation(from the quran) may not be a consensus among Quranists. There are some Quranists who admit outside revelation but downgrade it’s importance.

 

Our first study on revelatory phenomena stars with Surah Anfal. The eight Surah of the Qur’an revealed in regards to the Battle of Badr. This important event took place in 624 AD, or two years after hijra.  At Badr, the muslims won an important victory which also happened to be the first full scale engagement with the Quraish. It also initiated a long standing war between themselves and the Quraish that would go on for another six years.  Surah anfal was believed to be inspired to the prophet subsequent to the battle. We will limit our study to Surah 8:7 as this is enough for context.

“Recall that GOD promised you victory over a certain group, but you still wanted to face the weaker group. It was GOD's plan to establish the truth with His words, and to defeat the disbelievers.” (Surah 8:7)

 

Surah 8:7 inform is asking the believers to remember a past event. In the past God promised victory. This victory was evidently against one of two groups of people. Despite God’s promise, the believers wanted to engage the weaker of the two opponents.  The believers were hoping for a battle against a trade caravan led Abu Sufyan which was evidently easier to tackle. They were not looking to fight a giant army of Quraish folks led by Abu Jahl. God however had different intentions than the believers and found it in His wisdom to have the Muslims fight the stronger of the two groups, which in this case was the army of Quraish.

In summary we are asked to recall the promise that God made to the believers. Obviously, the promise was made at time prior to the actual battle of Badr. At this point the Prophet Muhammad told his followers that God would provide a victory to the people and they thus should not despair.  But where in the Qur’an do we find this promise that God made to the believers? Is there a verse with the promise mentioned that the Qur’an makes reference to?

 

There is absolutely no verse in the Qur’an that tells contains the initial promise that Surah 8:7 mentions.  Was the promise just something Muhammad said based on conjecture? No believer would take that position.  How would the Prophet Muhammad know there would there would be victory unless a revelation was sent to him? It is evident that the Qur’an is referring to a revelation that the Prophet Muhammad received. The revelation that the Prophet Muhammad received was given in the form of a prophecy about victory which the Muslims would enjoy over their opponents. Furthermore, this revelation was not in the Qur’an but given to the Prophet Muhammad outside of the Qur’an.

 

The Qur’an refers to the battle of Badr  elsewhere. “You told the believers,” GOD has granted you victory at Badr, despite your weakness. Therefore, you shall observe GOD, to show your appreciation. Is it not enough that your Lord supports you with three thousand angels, sent down?"(3:123-124) 3:124 is referring again to the promise the Prophet made in the past. We note that 3:124 specifies that the believers would receive divine assistance with an army of angels coming to their aide.  There is however no prophecy  in the Qur’an  where it is promised that angels would come to the rescue. The contents of the prophecy can only be found in history books. Yet we must believe it occurred if we are to believe the Qur’an.

 

The next verse we will look at comes from Surah Baqarah and concerns the changing of the Qiblah. When the Muslims went to Medina they prayed with the Jews in the same direction towards Jerusalem. After about 16 months the Prophet Muhammad received divine instructions to change the direction of prayer towards Mecca. This created a controversy with the Jews of Medina. 2:143  “We thus made you an impartial community, that you may serve as witnesses among the people, and the messenger serves as a witness among you. We changed the direction of your original Qiblah only to distinguish those among you who readily follow the messenger from those who would turn back on their heels. It was a difficult test, but not for those who are guided by GOD. GOD never puts your worship to waste. GOD is Compassionate towards the people, Most Merciful.”  (Please note that I do not consider R.K’s translation accurate here)

What is the verse telling us about the change in prayer direction? wa ma ja'alna l-qibla allati kunta alayha -We made your former prayer direction only so that we could know who would follow..(Kaskas) It is well known that the Muslims prayed towards Jerusalem as we said above.  Did the Muhammad randomly decide to just pray towards Jerusalem because the Jews did the same?  This not an option for a believer in the qur’an.  The verse 2:143 says “wa ma ja’alna liqbla” that We did not establish the Qibla..(except (illa…) to make evident who was following the truth.) It is clear from the Qur’an that God is attributing the initial command to pray towards Jerusalem to Himself. 

 

But where in the Qur’an does it say God ordered prayers towards Jerusalem? The answer is that no such verse exists.  The Qur’an thus referencing a commandment  to the believers through the Prophet Muhamad that is not listed inside the Qur’an. We have clear proof that Muhammad received commandments by God through revelation outside of the Qur’an. Now this was obviously a temporary commandment of God. The fact that the command had a time limited application should be good reason to show why the Qur’an did not include this abrogated commandment inside itself. And more could be discussed about the role of Qur’an and outside revelation in forming Islamic law. But for now let us limit our discussion to the point that a commandment came to Muhammad outside of the Qur’an.

 

Another situation that is well known is when the Prophet married his adopted son’s Zayd’s ex-wife. The marriage between the prophet and Zaynab became a source of controversy in later times. However the Qur’an criticizes the way the Prophet handled the situation: “Recall that you said to the one who was blessed by GOD, and blessed by you, "Keep your wife and reverence GOD," and you hid inside yourself what GOD wished to proclaim. Thus, you feared the people, when you were supposed to fear only GOD. When Zeid was completely through with his wife, we had you marry her, in order to establish the precedent that a man may marry the divorced wife of his adopted son. GOD's commands shall be done.” (33:37)

 

Surah Azhab informs us that God overturned the custom the Arabs had in which a man is unable to marry the wife of an adopted son.  The prophet however was fearful that people would criticized him for marrying Zayd’s ex-wife. The Qur’an therefor reprimands the Prophet for fearing people when he should have only feared God Almighty.  The Qur’an says about the incident “you hid inside yourself what God wished to proclaim” (wa tukhfi fee nafsika ma allahu mubdihi)  What was it that God intended to proclaim? The answer is of course that God permitted marriage between men and the  ex-wives of their adopted children.  But the reference in 33:37 to God’s proclamation can not be found anywhere in the Qur’an except this verse. Therefor the Qur’an is reference a revelation that was given to the Prophet Muhammad at an earlier time.

 

 Another incident in which the Qur’an makes reference to the Prophet being provided knowledge outside of the Qur’an itself is in Surah at Tahrim. The Surah was revealed during a situation in which the prophet was temporarily separated from his wives. “The prophet had trusted some of his wives with a certain statement, then one of them spread it, and GOD let him know about it. He then informed his wife of part of the issue, and disregarded part. She asked him, "Who informed you of this?" He said, "I was informed by the Omniscient, Most Cognizant." (66:3)   The Qur’an explains that the Prophet trusted his wives about something in confidence. Unfortunately they did not heed wisdom and instead conveyed the information where it was not supposed to be.  The Qur’an states that God let the Prophet know about what occurred.  Again, there is no verse in the Qur’an that informs the prophet of such details. We only know about it because the Qur’an makes a reference to the verse in past tense.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Institute of Rashad Khalifa Studies

 The Institute of Rashad Khalifa Studies  Welcome to the Institute of Rashad Khalifa Studies . Welcome to IRKS! Find out how to get a Ph.D. ...